Sell to us

How it is handled through CardCat

Home / Sell to us

Selling Your Collection

Got a collection gathering dust? Let's take a look

Clearing out a binder, stepping away from Magic: The Gathering, or sitting on a bulk box you’ve never quite gotten around to sorting? We’d love to take a look.

We buy Magic: The Gathering collections of any size — from a handful of singles to full bulk collections built up over years. No bidding wars, no listing cards one by one to strangers, and no pressure to accept anything you’re not comfortable with.

How it works

Reach out — a rough list, a Manabox link, photos, or simply “a few boxes, not totally sure what’s inside” is a perfectly fine place to start.
We review — we compare against current market data, primarily using Cardmarket’s EU listings, to make sure our numbers are grounded in reality.
You get an offer — honest, clearly explained, and completely no-obligation. You will most often get an offer within a fews days.
You decide — accept, decline, or ask us anything in between; there’s no pressure either way, and no hard feelings if it’s not the right fit.
We handle the rest — once you say yes, we arrange shipping details and payment together, keeping you informed the whole way.

What affects the offer

Condition matters, a lot. We grade using the same Cardmarket EU standard used across the European market, so a Near Mint card is worth meaningfully more than a heavily played one — and we’ll always explain exactly why.
Bulk is priced as bulk. Commons and other low-value cards are valued as a batch rather than card by card. This is standard practice across the trading card industry and keeps the process quick and fair for both sides.
We price against real market data, not wishful thinking. Our offers are based on what Magic: The Gathering cards are actually selling for on Cardmarket, not inflated asking prices you might see elsewhere online.

A few honest notes

Asking prices on marketplaces and social media are often considerably higher than what cards actually sell for — we’ll always walk you through how we arrived at our number, so there are no surprises.

Not sure whether your collection is even worth reaching out about? Reach out anyway. A good number of the collections we’ve bought started with someone being unsure too.

Declining our offer is always completely fine — there’s no obligation at any point in the process, and we’d genuinely rather you feel good about the decision than rushed into it.